Start Something: Focus on what you want vs. what you want to stop


"That's it. No more sugar (Starting Monday)."
We've all drawn the line in the sand. The problem is, we draw the line in the sand so close to the crashing waves that the tide washes it out by the end of the week. I've made more "no more" promises than anyone reading this. (Late-night snacking and I have an on again/off again relationship - no judging). We've all heard that knowing what you don't want is a good starting point, and I agree. However, I agree with a caveat. If you know what you don't want, it's important to know what you do want, or what you want to work towards, because when you say "no more," you're essentially ripping something out of your habitual life, and now there's an empty hole.
Bare Dirt from what you're stopping
Let's imagine a beautiful, lush flower garden. It's inevitable that a weed will eventually find its way into it. If you pull out the weed and leave the dirt bare, by the time you come back a couple of weeks later, you'll be pulling weeds again.
Bare ground doesn't stay bare. Something grows there. If you don't plant what you want or carefully cultivate it, the weeds will take back the empty space. Similarly, habits tend to act in the same way. If you take away a habit, you leave an empty space, and guess what shows up... late-night snacking (or whatever you're trying to pluck from your life).
What the research found about starting vs. stopping
In the Nov. 1 issue I mentioned previously, a Swedish study of more than 1,000 resolutions. People with "start" goals succeeded about 59% of the time at a year. People with "stop" goals landed around 47%.
One of the researchers, Per Carlbring, put it plainly: "You can't erase a behavior; you can only swap it for another one." Want to cut sweets? He suggested aiming for fruit several times a day instead. John Norcross saw the same pattern decades ago. Early in the year, the resolvers who made it were the ones who built in a healthy substitute for old behaviors.
What the old habit was doing for you
Here's the layer most people skip. The habit you want to drop was providing a job. The late-night scrolling gives you a break from thinking. The drink after work marks the line between "on" and "off". The snack is a small reward at the end of a long day.
Within my coaching, I reference the surface, the undertow, and the bedrock. The undertow here is a real need underneath a behavior you don't love. Rip the behavior out, and the need is still there, possibly louder than before.
So, along with "What do I stop?" ask a second question: "What need was that meeting, and what else could meet it?"
The fair pushback
I hear you; you're probably saying that some goals really are "stop" goals. Quitting smoking is a relevant one in my family, and I realize how difficult certain goals are. Carlbring admitted it's harder to rephrase a habit you repeat numerous times a day.
That's fair. I'll give it to you. However, you can still pair the stop with a start the moment the old habit shows up: "When I want a cigarette after lunch, I'll walk around the building first." The stop stays. The start gives it something to stand in. Another way to see this is in James Clear's Atomic Habits, where he references habit stacking and habit replacement.
Try this: Stop-to-start rewrite (10 minutes)
Write the "stop" or "less" version of your resolution.
When does the old habit usually show up? Time, place, mood, people associated, etc.
What does it give you? Comfort, a break, connection, numbness, reward, etc.
What else could give you that, in a way that you'd be proud of and that works for you?
Rewrite it: "When _____, I will start _____."
Here's an example:
Stop: Scrolling my phone in bed.
Shows up: 10 p.m., exhausted, kid(s) finally asleep.
Gives me: A break from everything; I don't have to think.
Something better: A paperback fictional book.
Start: "When I get in bed, I'll read 10 pages. The phone will charge in the other room.
Ask yourself:
What job has my old habit been doing?
What would I plant in that space if I chose on purpose?
Go from Drifting, To Driven!
James Seastrom is a U.S. Navy veteran and ICF-credentialed coach who spent 20 years developing teams before moving into Corporate leadership at Oracle NetSuite, where he learned that performance follows people: invest in their growth, and the results follow. He founded Strom Coaching on one idea: most people don't lose their way in one bad decision. They drift. Today he facilitates leadership development courses at Stagen Leadership Academy and coaches service members through career transition to civilian life.




Comments